Idaho: The Phantom Jogger of Canyon Hill
There are rumors of many hauntings in Caldwell, Idaho’s centuries-old Canyon Hill Cemetery, but the one that gets the most attention is the Midnight Jogger. As with many of the best urban legends, you have to do your part to get her attention: In this case it involves parking between certain trees in the cemetery at night. Do it right, and the legless apparition will knock on your window to let you know she’s there, then continue on her route. It’s creepy as hell, though now it’s only the second-worst image conjured when you think of sinister joggers.
Where it came from: The origins are unknown, though considering there’s another conspiratorial legend that the entire state of Idaho doesn’t actually exist, perhaps the jogger is just a creation of a deranged and deceptive government.